An NFL Nut.

Football stuff.

detroit lions

Matthew Stafford to the Detroit Lions a Lose-Lose Situation

Chances are you’ve seen a mock draft in the months since the Super Bowl.

In fact, I’m willing to bet you’ve seen a few dozen of them, and I’d also wager that Matthew Stafford, the quarterback out of Georgia with the rocket arm and the naturally curly hair, features prominently at the top of most of those mocks, to the Detroit Lions.

This is a problem.

Stafford to the Lions is a mistake in waiting. That has nothing to do with Stafford himself and everything to do with the Lions themselves.

Stafford has done nothing but ease concerns with a sharp mind, strong arm, and nearly flawless workouts.

However, the Detroit Lions drafting Matthew Stafford—or any quarterback—first overall is a recipe to ruin the kid and set the team back another three years in rebuilding.

As Lions fans, we are grateful to be done with the Matt Millen era, albeit with a chalky taste in our mouths, a few deep bruises, and a lot of bitterness. Still, does anybody have a guess who Millen would be looking at taking first overall in the 2009 NFL Draft?

More than likely, Matthew Stafford.

The greatest knock on Matt Millen while he was in charge of the Lions was that he valued “skill” players higher than “core” players. The temptation is to only remember the receiver picks, but quarterback is a “skill” position, too. Indeed, Charles Rogers was a poor pick, and Mike Williams was atrocious, but what about Joey Harrington?

In 2002, Harrington was to be the “savior” for the Lions. Picked third overall (like Matt Ryan, for instance), Harrington was faced with high expectations to start producing wins on a team that just wasn’t built for winning.

Poor defense and line play meant Harrington never found a comfort zone (and that was before Ford Field started booing him), and we all were left wondering what could have been. Now what was a promising career sits on the third string in New Orleans watching Drew Brees assault passing records and the playoffs.

Now here we are, seven years later, facing the same dilemma. Offensive line play is still poor, with Lions QBs sacked 52 times in 2008, or roughly once every 10 pass attempts. The defense is historically bad, with the 2008 Lions giving up the second-most points in a single season in NFL history.

Yet somehow, a vast majority of “experts” think Stafford—another QB with “savior” qualities—is the first step to rebuilding.

Thanks, but doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting different results is called insanity.

If I stuck my hand in a hot waffle iron in 2002 and burned it so badly that I finally decided in 2006 that it just wasn’t going to work out and traded it to the Miami Dolphins for a conditional sixth-round pick, do you think I’d wait until 2009 and do it again?

That waffle iron is still going to be hot, and the Lions still can’t protect a quarterback or stop an opposing offense, just like in 2002.

Drafting a quarterback who might throw a tight spiral on plays he doesn’t get his head taken off is not good football sense.

This is known as the “David Carr” Philosophy, adopted in Detroit as the “Charlie Batch/Joey Harrington/Jon Kitna/Dan Orlovsky” Philosophy. Stafford’s strong arm is only going to help Detroit if he’s not using it to stiff-arm rushing defenders.

Building an offensive line that keeps your quarterback’s head on his shoulders is good football sense, and Baylor’s Jason Smith is the perfect step in the right direction.

The only question left is whether Martin Mayhew has really learned from Millen’s mistakes, as he says he has—or is he every bit the Millen protégé Lions fans fear he is?

The future of the Lions—and Stafford’s career—rests on the answer.

About the Author

Dean Holden is the "Voice of the Lions" on NFLTouchdown.com. Check it out for in-depth analysis on the Lions and all 31 other NFL teams.

http://www.nfltouchdown.com/category/detroit-lions/

How will the Detroit Lions do this season?

With the draft and new free agency aquisitions this off season, what will the record be for the lions?

are you kidding me? They are going to be horrible just like the past few years. They may have chosen a standout WR in Calvin Johnson, but Im willing to bet Calvin cant block a Brian Urlacher from blitzing the QB. And he damn sure cant throw the ball to himself. Detroit has many...MANY problems and they start in the front office. Once those are takin care of, and they get players to fit a system, instead of players w/ excellent stats, they will be pretty good.

They just dont have any direction, or really know where they want to go with their team. I have been waiting for years for the lions to turn it around, and its sadly to say I think we are going to be waiting at least 3-4 more years before we see that happen!

NFL's Suh can't wait for World Cup

Detroit Lions $6.99 Detroit Lions - Poster

The Story of the Detroit Lions $37.17 The Story of the Detroit Lions

Detroit Lions 2012 Calendar $10.44 Detroit Lions 2012 Calendar

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Door Mat $33.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Door Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Door Mat - Size: 18" x 30

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - TAILGATER Mat $144.38 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - TAILGATER Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - TAILGATER Mat - Size: 5' x 6'

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - ULTI-MAT $169.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - ULTI-MAT NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - ULTI-MAT - Size: 5' x 8'

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Runner Mat $72.13 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Runner Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Runner Mat - Size: 29.5" x 72

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Starter Mat $27.08 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Starter Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Starter Mat - Size: 20" x 30

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Football Mat $33.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Football Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Football Mat - Size: 22" x 35

Detroit Lions Flared Shooter $13.45 Detroit Lions Flared Shooter Detroit Lions Flared Shooter

Detroit Lions Dangle Earrings $9.87 Detroit Lions Dangle Earrings Detroit Lions Dangle Earrings

Detroit Lions Logo Necklace $10.55 Detroit Lions Logo Necklace Detroit Lions Logo Necklace

Detroit Lions Earrings $9.87 Detroit Lions Earrings Enameled Pewter Team Earrings - Detroit Lions

Detroit Lions 3D Magnet $10.95 Detroit Lions 3D Magnet Sculpted and Enameled Team Magnet - Detroit Lions

Detroit Lions Team Toothbrush $10.25 Detroit Lions Team Toothbrush Detroit Lions Team Toothbrush

Detroit Lions 2011 Logo $9.99 Detroit Lions 2011 Logo - Photo

2010 Detroit Lions Composite $9.99 2010 Detroit Lions Composite - Photo

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Fan Brands Mat $16.03 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Fan Brands Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Fan Brands Mat - Size:

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Cell Phone Grips Mat $16.03 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Cell Phone Grips Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Cell Phone Grips Mat - Size:

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Rug 5x8 Mat $271.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Rug 5x8 Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Rug 5x8 Mat - Size: 5' x 8'

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Rug 4x6 Mat $186.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Rug 4x6 Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Rug 4x6 Mat - Size: 4' x 6'

Detroit Lions Large Emblem Zippo $36.95 Detroit Lions Large Emblem Zippo Detroit Lions Large Emblem Zippo

Pewter Emblem Detroit Lions Cordial $16.95 Pewter Emblem Detroit Lions Cordial Pewter Emblem Detroit Lions Cordial

Detroit Lions Trailer Hitch LG $33.95 Detroit Lions Trailer Hitch LG Detroit Lions Trailer Hitch LG

Detroit Lions Flashing Pin/Pendant $9.45 Detroit Lions Flashing Pin/Pendant Detroit Lions Flashing Pin/Pendant

Detroit Lions Team Logo Pin $8.95 Detroit Lions Team Logo Pin Detroit Lions Team Logo Pin

Detroit Lions Executive Key Chain $9.95 Detroit Lions Executive Key Chain Detroit Lions Executive Key Chain

Detroit Lions Helmet Key Ring $10.95 Detroit Lions Helmet Key Ring Detroit Lions Helmet Key Ring

Detroit Lions Candle Set (2) $20.95 Detroit Lions Candle Set (2) Detroit Lions Candle Set (2)

Detroit Lions Logo Key Ring $10.95 Detroit Lions Logo Key Ring Detroit Lions Logo Key Ring

Detroit Lions Design Key Ring $10.95 Detroit Lions Design Key Ring Detroit Lions Design Key Ring

Lions in Zoo, Detroit, Michigan $24.99 Lions in Zoo, Detroit, Michigan - Premium Poster

NFL Detroit Lions Pool Cue $85 NFL Detroit Lions Pool Cue

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Vinyl Cargo Mat $38.13 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Vinyl Cargo Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Vinyl Cargo Mat - Size: 31" x 31

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - NFL Golf Putting Green Mat $44.93 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - NFL Golf Putting Green Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - NFL Golf Putting Green Mat - Size: 18"x72

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Starter Mat $27.08 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Starter Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Starter Mat - Size: 20" x 30

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - All-Star Mat $50.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - All-Star Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - All-Star Mat - Size: 34" x 44.5

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Car Mats 2 Piece Front $42.38 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Car Mats 2 Piece Front NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Car Mats 2 Piece Front - Size: 18" x 27

Detroit Lions Toothbrush Holder $16.95 Detroit Lions Toothbrush Holder Another team pictured, but available in your team.

Detroit Lions Ornament Football $20.35 Detroit Lions Ornament Football Another team pictured, but available in your team.

Detroit Lions Drinking Cup $16.95 Detroit Lions Drinking Cup Another team pictured, but available in your team.

2009 Detroit Lions Team Logo $9.99 2009 Detroit Lions Team Logo - Photo

Detroit Lions 2011 Team Composite $9.99 Detroit Lions 2011 Team Composite - Photo

Detroit Lions Throwback $22 Detroit Lions Throwback Detroit Lions Throwback Vintage wool pennants designed with vibrantly colored embroidery and applique. These nostalgic pennants are individually hand-crafted.

Detroit Lions Glossy Team Pin $8.95 Detroit Lions Glossy Team Pin High Gloss Hard Enamel Team Pin - Detroit Lions

Detroit Lions 21x31 Bedrest $38.99 Unbelievably comfortable- this Detroit Lions bedrest is the perfect accessory. Whether you are reading in bed or playing video games in front of the sofa- this Detroit Lions bedrest delivers relaxing support. Filled with a special poly-styrene blend- this Detroit Lions bedrest is easily moved from room to room. Officially licensed by the NFL.

Detroit Lions 5-Pin Set $34.99 Own 5 unique and collectible pins with this Detroit Lions 5-Pin Set. These are perfect for displaying on your desk or mantle and include a latching case to keep them fully protected. *Great gift for a Detroit Lions fan *Officially licensed by the NFL Great gift for a Detroit Lions fan Officially licensed by the NFL

Detroit Lions Traditions Banner $22 Detroit Lions Traditions Banner Detroit Lions Traditions Banner Vintage wool pennants designed with vibrantly colored embroidery and applique. These nostalgic pennants are individually hand-crafted.

Detroit Lions Pigskin Pennant $24.55 Detroit Lions Pigskin Pennant Detroit Lions Pigskin Pennant Vintage wool pennants designed with vibrantly colored embroidery and applique. These nostalgic pennants are individually hand-crafted.

Detroit Lions Photo $5.95 Detroit Lions Photo Show support for your favorite team with this high quality full color photo! This 8x10 features the logo of the Detroit Lions and will look great displayed in any fan's home or office.

Redskins Lions Football: Detroit, MI - Lions Flags $124.99 Carlos Osorio Redskins Lions Football: Detroit, MI - Lions Flags - Wall Mural

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - NFL Carpet Tiles Mat $237.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - NFL Carpet Tiles Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - NFL Carpet Tiles Mat - Size: 18â€Â�x 18â€Â�, 20 Tiles Per Box

Detroit Lions 20x30 Mat $28.99 Score a touchdown at your next Detroit Lions themed party with this Detroit Lions Decorative Mat. Featuring a vibrantly-colored Lions team graphic- this Detroit Lions Decorative Mat will undoubtedly prove who the biggest Lions fan on the block is. Mildew and stain resistant to withstand even the wildest parties UV stable for indoor/outdoor use Measures a solid 20'' x 30'' Skid resistant foam urethane backing 100% non-woven polyester Officially licensed by the NFL

Detroit Lions Ruffled Valance $40 Detroit Lions Ruffled Valance is available from bedbathstore.com for only $29.99. Shop bedbathstore for the best price and quality with Free Shipping.

Detroit Lions Shower Curtain $65 Detroit Lions Shower Curtain is available from bedbathstore.com for only $49.99. Shop bedbathstore for the best price and quality with Free Shipping.

Detroit Lions Throw Pillow $27.5 Detroit Lions Throw Pillow is available from bedbathstore.com for only $22.00. Shop bedbathstore for the best price and quality with Free Shipping.

Detroit Lions Football Mat $29.99 A true sports fans room wouldn't be complete without the addition of this attractive Detroit Lions Football Mat!Officially licensed by the NFL

Detroit Lions Jersey Flag $34.99 If you are a fan of the Detroit Lions and want to support them year-round with this Detroit Lions Jersey Flag. This one-of-a-kind item features the teams vibrant team colors and logo. Show that you are a die-hard Lions fan with this piece of team gear. Makes a great gift Quality construction Officially licensed

Detroit Lions NFL Pool Ball Set $199 Detroit Lions NFL Pool Ball Set

Detroit Lions Edition Nfl Datastick Swiv $13.99 DETROIT LIONS EDITION NFL DATASTICK SWIV

Detroit Lions Helmet Lamp $129.99 Still looking for that perfect accessory for your game room- den- or man-cave? Look no further than this Detroit Lions Helmet Lamp. Built from a replica football helmet nearly identical to those the Lions wear on the field- this Detroit Lions Helmet Lamp is an absolute must-have for the truest of Detroit Lions fans. Helmet secured to a sturdy base Measures approximately 24'' in height Uses a standard 60-watt bulb (not included) Officially licensed by the NFL

Detroit Lions Authentic Mini Helmet Unsigned $46.76 Detroit Lions Authentic Mini Helmet Unsigned Detroit Lions Authentic Mini Helmet Unsigned

Pewter Logo Detroit Lions Coffee Mug $17.95 Pewter Logo Detroit Lions Coffee Mug Pewter Logo Detroit Lions Coffee Mug

Detroit Lions Chain Necklace & Pewter Pendant $12.95 Detroit Lions Chain Necklace & Pewter Pendant Detroit Lions Chain Necklace & Pewter Pendant

Detroit Lions Leather Necklace & Pewter Pendant $12.95 Detroit Lions Leather Necklace & Pewter Pendant Detroit Lions Leather Necklace & Pewter Pendant

Detroit Lions Team Design 3rd Ed. Pin $8.95 Detroit Lions Team Design 3rd Ed. Pin Enameled Pewter Team Design 3rd edition Pin - Detroit Lions

Detroit Lions Square Leather Key Ring $10.95 Detroit Lions Square Leather Key Ring Detroit Lions Square Leather Key Ring

Detroit Lions Small Leather Key Ring $10.95 Detroit Lions Small Leather Key Ring Detroit Lions Small Leather Key Ring

2010 Detroit Lions Composite 8x10 Photo $5.74 2010 Detroit Lions Composite 8x10 Photo 2010 Detroit Lions Composite 8x10 Photo

Matt Stafford Autographed Detroit Lions Mini Helmet $181.94 Matt Stafford Autographed Detroit Lions Mini Helmet Matt Stafford Autographed / Signed Detroit Lions Mini Helmet

Detroit Lions Bottle Opener Key Ring $8.95 Detroit Lions Bottle Opener Key Ring Detroit Lions Bottle Opener Key Ring

Signed Bennie Blades Photo - Detroit Lions 8x10 $36.55 Signed Bennie Blades Photo - Detroit Lions 8x10 Bennie Blades Autographed / Signed Detroit Lions 8x10 Photo

Detroit Lions Stadium 22x28 Canvas Art $46.75 Detroit Lions Stadium 22x28 Canvas Art Detroit Lions Stadium 22x28 Canvas Art

Barry Sanders Unautographed Detroit Lions 8x10 Photo $8 Barry Sanders Unautographed Detroit Lions 8x10 Photo Color unautographed 8x10 Photo of Detroit Lions Superstar Barry Sanders.

Detroit Lions Replica Mini Helmet Unsigned $38.74 Detroit Lions Replica Mini Helmet Unsigned Detroit Lions Replica Mini Helmet Unsigned

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Vinyl Utility Mat 14"x17 $16.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Vinyl Utility Mat 14"x17 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Vinyl Utility Mat 14"x17" - Size:

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Mirror Covers Small Mat $16.88 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Mirror Covers Small Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Mirror Covers Small Mat - Size:

NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Mirror Covers Large Mat $18.58 NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Mirror Covers Large Mat NFL - Detroit Lions Detroit Lions - Uniform Inspired - Mirror Covers Large Mat - Size:

Tags: detroit, detroit lions 2009 schedule, detroit lions roster, detroit lions schedule, detroit lions tickets, detroit lions.com, football, lions, news, sports

This entry was posted on Friday, December 25th, 2009 at 2:34 pm and is filed under Uncategorized. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.